Rodrigo y Gabriela: Tamacun
I first heard these guys a few months ago. They're a virtuoso Mexican guitar duo and they play a sort of metal/flamenco hybrid that is really fantastic -- energetic and extremely talented. Their album received lots of good press (though not from everyone for their self-titled debut album.
Their album contains two cover songs, of "Stairway to Heaven" and Metallica's "Orion." Both are great, as are the originals on the record, especially "Diablo Rojo" and "Juan Loco." Here's the thing that interests me, though. My favorite song on the album is the lead-off track, "Tamacun." Take a look and listen, and pay special attention to what I guess you could call the chorus, the part that Rodrigo picks:
Sound familiar? To me, it sounds an awful lot like the melody line to Britney Spears' "Oops, I Did It Again," just sped-up and flamenco-ized:
A listen to a performance of the song by Richard Thompson might make it a little easier to hear it, as he does it on acoustic guitar without the layers of production.
What's odd to me is that I've never read this mentioned anywhere. Ever. Here's a album that got quite a bit of alternative press, and even some mainstream notice (Rodrigo Y Gabriela performed on the Letterman show). Much of the press talked about the two covers on the album, but never once have I seen a reference to what appears to be a third, uncredited cover, and a cover of a mega-hit from less than a decade ago. Strange. Am I the only one who hears it?
Labels: music
5 Comments:
I'm not hearing a cover, but two songs using the same limited palette.
The chorus section of each tune is restricted to four chords -- Am, G, C, E7 (the "Heart and Soul" chords for minor key songs). R&G's chord progression goes around that circle four times, where the Spears tune jumbles it a little and does this progression -- Am E7 Am G C G C E7 -- twice.
The melodies are just jogging up and down the scale to go along with the current chord. Just about any two songs that restrict themselves to the same chord choices and melodic runs are going to sound like each other at some point. But I think it's as much a coincidence here as it would be with "Every Breath You Take" and "Making Love Out Of Nothing At All".
(Thanks for giving me an excuse to listen to the RT cover of the Spears tune again. I love that one!)
The first time I heard this song, I thought, "How funny -- it's a Latin guitar cover of a pop tune!" But I couldn't place what the tune was. I'm not sure you're right about Britney, though. I keep hearing a snippet of a lyric in my head that goes something like "I want you back in my arms" or heart or whatever.
In fact, tonight, I found your blog because I've been searching the web trying to answer this mystery for myself, and can't find any mention anywhere.
Aha! I've been hearing "Woman in Love" by Barbra Streisand --
I am a woman in love
And I'd do anything
To get you into my world
And hold you within....
Mike, that makes a lot of sense, even to this untrained ear. Especially now that Diane mentions "Woman In Love," which I can totally hear echoes of as well.
There are some similarities to both the Spears and the Streisand tunes, but I think Mike nails it. This is probably just dumb luck.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home